Original: October 10, 2023
Revised: October 21, 2023
October 7, 2023 ... in Israel
(my Israeli ties springing up)It is going to be messy ... and some clarity is needed
The horrific attack by Hamas on Israel will have messy consequences. When the Israeli PM and many others tell us that things will dramatically change in Gaza, they obviously mean it. Yes, there will be many civilian casualties in Gaza. Yes, we will all be reminded that the Gaza situation was not sustainable long term. Yes, it is true that the Palestinian aspirations cannot be neglected forever. Yes, there will be finger pointing at the failure of the Israeli intelligence services and that failure will bear on Netanyahu's shoulders and will most likely lead to his downfall.
BUT ... this ISN'T the time to discuss any of these issues. This IS the time to reflect on the horrors, condemn the atrocities without any ifs-and-buts, squarely support Israel's right to respond accordingly and only at the end of this war unwanted by Israel, we should begin figuring out what went wrong intelligence-wise and try to seriously address the Palestinian situation.
I lived in Israel in the late '70s and loved the kibutz life, although I did not spent as much time in any of them as I would have liked. I played bridge with Palestinian graduate students at Technion in Haifa, I worked with Palestinian colleagues in the US and I do not feel animosity towards Palestinians in general. But I am outraged more than anything to see the current carnage perpetrated by Hamas terrorists (not militants, not fighters, ... just terrorists). Which carnage happened mostly in rural areas and kibutzim bordering Gaza.